Edition 24: 1–9 August, 2025

VIEW FROM THE WORLD

Presumed Guilty

Presunto Culpable

Mexico
2009 — 91' / Color

1

Synopsis

In the Mexican penal system, one is guilty until proven innocent. This leads to a very uncomfortable reality: prisons full of people serving time for crimes they didn’t commit. Presumed Guilty narrates the story of José Antonio Zúñiga Rodriguez, nicknamed Toño, who was mistakenly accused of murder and condemned to twenty years in jail for being poor and in the wrong place at the wrong time. His case would have been one of many unfortunate stories, but lawyers Roberto Hernández and Layda Negrete decided to get involved and publicize the injustice.

Director Biography

Roberto was born in Monterrey, Mexico, and is completing a doctorate in public policy at the University of California, Berkeley. “Presumed Guilty” is his first feature documentary.
Geoffrey was born in Melbourne, Australia, and has made over twenty television documentaries. His film “The English Surgeon” (07) was named the best international feature documentary at the 2008 Hot Docs Canadian International Documentary Festival.

Director

Geoffrey Smith

Roberto Hernández

Producer

Layda Negrete

Martha Sosa

Roberto Hernández

Yissel Ibarra

Cinematographer

Amir Galván

John Grillo

Luis Damián Sánchez

Editor

Felipe Gómez

Roberto Hernández

Sound

David Melchor

Nikolas Klaus

Contact

Upfront Films
Baldersgade 6
DK-2200 Copenhagen N
Denmark